Like many who’ve pointed out on their own reviews, one of the major things to bear in mind is that this novel takes place in the head of Thomas Cromwell. It certainly helps when the word ‘he’ is thrown about like it’s going out of fashion.
Hilary Mantel takes a controlled and measured pace with this novel, writing in a style that sets it aside from the countless novels set during the reign of Henry VIII that I found in my own humble opinion quite refreshing.
The first in the Thomas Cromwell trilogy, it begins with his rise to power following the fall of Cardinal Wolsey and ends with the execution of Thomas More.
I find that with most writers delving into this period of history, they settle themselves in the More camp or the Cromwell. As this is the first in a trilogy chronicling the life of Cromwell, we know where Mantel has erected her banners. Therefore, any time her protagonist comes into contact with Thomas More, the doomed high chancellor is painted in a very dubious light. This in itself doesn’t affect the novel, I just feel compelled to point this out through experience.
Her take on the many historical characters is both intriguing and entertaining (particularly her portrayal of the king as a fussy, spoilt man-child, which I care to agree regarding the unhinged tyrant that is Henry VIII). As cold as Queen Anne is written, Mantel subtly hints at her hold over the king and her own fears regarding the need to secure her place by providing an heir.
The book is no light read by any stretch of the imagination, and if those choosing to read this have no prior knowledge of the events that take place during this chaotic period in history, will certainly have a difficult time keeping up with what’s going on. Reading a few of the poorly rated reviews, I think that’s been one of the problems… possibly.
In any case, if you are thoroughly interested in the intrigues of the Tudor court, I’d definitely recommend this book. It gives a decent account of the power struggles of Henry’s reign from a deeply refreshing angle.
Graeme J Greenan 